Saturday, July 5, 2008

KoHam (Who Am I?)








"Hum ko apna saaya tak aksar be-zaar mila....

...Gham se ab ghabrana kaisa, gham sau baar mila..."

That's how I feel each time I have a brush with the Armed Forces these days...the most recent being less than 24 hours ago.

The Armed Forces that were my family, the cantonments that were my home, the Army uniforms, Insignias, Corps, Divisions, Formations and Mottos (e.g. Sarve Santu Niramaya; Veerta Hee Maan; Karm Hee Dharm; Sarvada Satark; Teevra Chaukas; Sarvatra Izzat-O-Iqbal and innumerable others), that were an integral part of my identity... they are all slipping away even as I write these words.

With every passing moment, the rift between me (nothing more than a humble "civilian") and the wonderful, cosmopolitan organisation that the Indian Armed Forces and their world is growing into a widening gorge that I fear I shall never be able to leap across.

I am, it appears, doomed to be viewed by those who, till recently were my own, (and from whom I derived my strongest and most important identity), as a suspicious character who seems to know slightly more about the Indian military establishment than they expect of a "civilian".

When members of the Division that my Mother once served in try to be evasive about who they are, how things are at the Div HQ and why the tank transporters are standing in Delhi, it does say a thing or two about their vision of me - a mere "civilian" (who should ideally be) far removed from the world of the Olive Green and the Battle Fatigues...

When an officer leading a military convoy on a National Highway is bewildered, stunned (and probably a tad worried), by the fact that I know not only his rank, but also his corp, his ribbons and his formation sign (and where they are based), he too is conveying the same message that the soldier in Delhi sent out loud and clear - "stay away; you seem to know too much about us and we don't know who you are...;don't know if you're truly someone who's lived his childhood and youth in Cantts or a Pakistani spy posing as an innocent civilian...;
you're too damn suspicious - seem to know too much; please stay away - we cannot divulge anything to you...not even whether your statement about the formation sign is correct..."

Of no significance is the fact that my father spent over three decades as an active member of the Army, serving in the AMC in positions as varied as Medical Officer to HoD - Neurology in places as diverse as Sri Ganganagar and Udhampur; it does not matter that my mother had also donned the OG uniform not once but for two terms of Short Service Commission; it matters not that I never thought myself to be a Bihari but an Indian belonging to the Armed Forces fraternity...that was my erroneous reading of my identity they say...

And this, when I never regarded the land of my ancestors as my own - when I was always (and shall always remain to be), more an army lad than a Bihari. Reminds me of what Jawaharlal Nehru once said of himself: "I have become a queer mixture of the East and the West, out of place everywhere, at home nowhere." I find myself in a similar quandary - and while I know not how much it hurt Nehru, it does hurt me beyond what words can convey...

O' how it hurts to be rendered homeless and without a family when entry to the Cantonments that I've grown up in and that hold some of my most priceless memories is restricted to me; when I am not allowed to walk into Command Hospital, Calcutta which I associate with the birth of my beloved brother; when the rank and file of the Armed Forces suddenly seem to have turned their backs on this member who was till recently one of them...

Going ahead, I can only see the rift widening as I follow my path in life and become progressively more "civilian" in the eyes of those who today don the OG Uniform and occupy the bunkers, offices, and hospitals of the Indian Army... May I have the strength to witness this and learn to live with the pains of my (erstwhile?) family forsaking me...



6 comments:

Dr. Anandmayee Sinha said...

a-that was too strong and sentimental. no one takes away anything from you. yes we do belong to the army and now out. pop doesnt even call himself a col anymore. and i have long forgotten i was in the army . now it is just zulekha and dubai.life is too dynamic .it changes-and we accept the change-that is the beauty-we are indians faujis biharis kayasthas ,global citizens,human race,a part of the universe. we dont have only one identity-it is multifold.my darling son no one can ever take away yoour identity-it is there always but you are continuously evolvngand growing-not a mere civilian. See what happened to Fd Marshall-that's what's life is about-actually-nothing -just a myth.love-mom

Pranay Sinha said...

Hi Bhaiya,
I can imagine how you felt and it is, indeed, a rankling feeling. However, if there's one thing that our sojourn in the army life should have taught us is that we have to keep moving on and getting over things; living in the present; treasuring the past, but not allowing it to hurt us by its distance and inaccessibility.
I obviously understand your citing the Nehru quote because I remember it frequently. However, I have determined that my identity should not and will not be determined by institutions, nationalities (definitely not) religion, or any other meaningless label; I hope to be identified by my deeds.
By the way, this piece is a very personal one and anyone who knows you cannot help but spot your personality oozing out of every sentence of this essay.

Love,
Sonu

The Wanderer said...

Hi Sonu,

Good point there about our deeds shaping our identity. I am completely in agreement with you there. That's how I live my life - not fettered by region, race, caste or religion. However, at times, one does feel the need to look for one's roots and find some measure of reassurance in the fact that we are still bound to our roots, which in my case happens to be the Armed Forces establishment.

I don't quite see how my personality is "oozing out of every sentence" in this essay, but would agree that it was more like a diary entry that found its way onto the blog.

As for being personal, I believe whoever has had a tussle within him about his/ her identity, would be able to relate to the thoughts that I present here. This is but a manifestation of me perceiving to have lost a bit of my identity each time the Army tries to shield something from my gaze. I'm sure others would also have their own tales of a similar nature, even if they did not pertain to the Army or the Armed Forces, but to anything that lent them identity.

Ashesh Prasann said...

Monu Bhaiya,
Revisiting our roots is always a less than satisfying experience. People and places move on and only memories remain. Going to Munger or Jamalpur today for Bua or Papa would be a very similar experience to what you experienced. Moreover, the army is one institution which survives because it moves on. We glorify sacrifices of our soldiers, but even that is in abstraction - as Amar Javan Jyoti or the like. What no one can take away from you are the values of the army life - etiquette, discipline, punctuality etc (I might be overstating the case!).

Unknown said...

hhmm..am an air force brat myself.i understand your hurt but i agree with your mom...life is to dynamic and we have to move on...embrace the new change and appreciate the past ;)

Bhagya said...

Those are amongst the most touching lines I have ever read and many a times felt as well, when a person is trying to figure out his/her own identity in the sea of people..Its painful when our own people refuse to recognise us and to accept us as a part of themselves..i can very well understand ur feeling of pain when you relate urself to Nehru's statement, "I have become a queer mixture of the East and the West, out of place everywhere, at home nowhere.." very much applicable to people like us for whom, this whole country is home but the home is really nowhere..

I don't know if I could really say anything here to give you comfort..But I would surely say one thing:
"Hum to dariyaa hain hamein apna hunar maloom hai..
Jidhar bhi jayenge hum raasta bana lenge.."

We don't really need to look at the past to find our identity..It lies within us and it will be with us wherever we are..

Hope that helps you feel a bit better about it,
Bhagya